仙珍圜

标题: 大家来谈谈对原地种的看法吧 [打印本页]

作者: Luien    时间: 2022-4-2 16:28
标题: 大家来谈谈对原地种的看法吧
本帖最后由 Luien 于 2022-4-2 16:30 编辑

其实偶然看到有店专门卖原地种,我个人第一反应是愤怒,因为原地种意味着对原生态环境的破坏以及利益熏心下人为付出的植物生命代价。后面我想通过该网上平台直接举报,但是几次举报均未成功,我就突然发现这种现象似乎并不受法律保护。而作为消费终端的人群来说,买与卖之间是否隔着原地或许也就没这么重要了,毕竟对普通民众来说,法无禁止皆可为。不知道大家对平台售卖的原地种是怎么看待的?
作者: yzjn911    时间: 2022-4-2 16:34
这么多年来一脉相承的商家套路
作者: 白云清波    时间: 2022-4-2 16:36
这样的话,普通玩家应该自主抵制吧。法律目前可能顾及不到这么细,商家就钻空子,这个我觉得不只是道德方面的问题
作者: 白云清波    时间: 2022-4-2 16:37
很多交易平台的管理工作者也不会是专业植物人员,不会懂这些。这个可真靠自觉了,但我怀疑有小部分说原始种的,应该是挂羊头卖狗肉
作者: 4199633    时间: 2022-4-2 16:49
这个不像原地的,可能是原地种子播出来的
作者: 小隐    时间: 2022-4-2 18:37
野货导致现在肉锥都快没人玩了
作者: cocozhang    时间: 2022-4-4 23:35
没有买卖就没有杀害。国外大佬普遍是保护性然后其中参杂一些图谋不轨的,我们这是直接奔着灭绝去的,这些植物不在华盛顿公约举报没有用。总之就是好自为之吧,利益面前谈什么脸。
作者: 东水瓶    时间: 2022-4-5 17:27
一个敢卖一个敢买反正我是不相信什么原产地,除非自己去挖的
作者: lux0711    时间: 2022-4-5 19:43
养好自己爱的植物就行。
作者: 也叫小黑    时间: 2022-4-6 08:58
便宜啊  有便宜的谁还买贵的
作者: 花開情爲誰    时间: 2022-4-6 10:40
不管买不买原产地,大家也得到了利益,毕竟如果有300%的利润,那么资本家们便会践踏世间的一切,这个不是也验证了这个说法吗?悲哀的同时,自己也因此得利了。
作者: 鲤鱼爱海狗    时间: 2022-4-6 15:01
真是产地的···完全属于破坏生态啊
作者: alexy    时间: 2022-4-6 19:44
从自己做起,不买原地
作者: ConoPhytums    时间: 2022-4-6 20:01
本帖最后由 ConoPhytums 于 2022-4-6 20:08 编辑

很纠结啊 一方面没有买卖就没有杀害是成立的,另一方面现在很多地方生态破坏的也很严重,导致一些物种濒临灭绝,比如我们最爱的拉登。试想可爱的拉登在花友手里是百般呵护, 在当地人眼里可能就直接被压路机碾过去了。比如下面这段Terry Smale 写的,一个地方因为建了一个矿场毁灭了拉登的很多种群。

Conophytum ratum is one of the more vulnerable species in the wild. There seem to have been 4 populations known for the typical large form of the species: Onder Namies (type locality), south of Achab se berg, Achab farm and the north-west foot of the Gamsberg. There do not seem to have been many plants at any of these localities, but the type locality was largely robbed out by a collector and the NW Gamsberg population has been destroyed by zinc mining. The plants at these localities grow (grew?) in flat quartz areas with just the top window exposed; they are often with C. maughanii which can look very similar in the wild situation. Wild plants are usually solitary and large, up to 40 - 50mm across. The Gamsberg itself is a flat-topped inselberg with a big crater on the west side. To the north-east there is a plateau region with some endemic species. In this area there is a substantial population of C. ratum which is much smaller than the type, only growing to 10-15mm diameter (even in cultivation). Furthermore it tends to flower in cultivation in mid-August, some 3-4 weeks earlier than the typical form. In my opinion, it constitutes a good subspecies and I wish that I had named it in the early 2000s after I had been shown it. It might have then received some protection from the mining operation. The mine is starting in the crater area but is now scheduled to move to the eastern part and this ecotype is unlikely to survive. The mining company has dug up the large common plants and is preserving them in a nursery for future landscaping when mining has finished, but no attention has been paid to the rare miniatures.




作者: M-O-    时间: 2022-4-7 10:29
怎么说呢?这是个很复杂的问题,要管理起来很难,因为标准不易确定。而且他只是**物种,并不算濒危物种。虽然说利益是源头,但是这些植物在国内活得也不是太差,总是会有人养的很好,这也算是一种异地保护吧。上述仅个人浅见
作者: wosivv    时间: 2022-4-7 10:33
利益相关,肉锥跌价,玩家受惠,不予评价




欢迎光临 仙珍圜 (http://www.xianzhenyuan.cn/) Powered by Discuz! X3